Wednesday, May 13, 2009

It's Well Past Time

Another day, another disaster.

The news yesterday that the “trust funds” for Medicare and Social Security will both be depleted before previously thought left me with the sense that the only way forward is through an honest and frank discussion about our current financial predicament. But too often those conversations, even between people who care about the subject, are so overwhelming that they don't proceed very far. To understand how much debt we already carry and the trillions more we face in the very near future is to understand what hopelessness feels like.

Some will want to focus on what happened to bring us to this brink of financial disaster. Others will just want to scream from the rooftops until everyone is outraged enough to act. But neither approach will move us closer to fixing the mess – and fix it we must. We can talk about how we got here later, but for now the focus needs to be on how to get out of this mess.

So let's talk.

The Medicare trust fund will pay out more than it takes in this year for the first time since it was created. It will continue to do so over the next 8 years until 2017 when it will be completely depleted. This projection assumes that the tax rates do not increase. As of today, only the first $100,000 (or so) that a person earns each year is taxed to fund Medicare and Social Security. That means the bulk of funding comes from low to middle wage earners.

But so what if Medicare fails? What does it have to do with those of us who don't utilize Medicare? Well, for those of us who work in health care, we can expect that hospitals, clinics and nursing homes will close. Quite simply, health care cannot survive on reimbursements from private insurers alone – even if those insurers were in better financial shape and not in danger of going off the cliff themselves. Health care providers (and our patients) would have to make due with much less and accept it as the norm.

If Medicare fails, those who pay for private health insurance plans through their employers will see their rates go up dramatically. Since the health care system will have to function at some level, if Medicare is underfunded and/or not available, the private insurers of the world will have to make up the difference. Thus, premiums will rise as will co-pays and out of pocket expenses, and the list of uncovered conditions and procedures will grow as insurers quickly go broke.

It's likely that tens of millions of people would be added to the 48 million currently without insurance in this country. How pathetic. As the last wealthy industrialized nation on Earth who does not provide even a minimal health care safety net for its citizens, we should hang our heads in collective shame. That we will abandon citizens who have faithfully paid their taxes each year and believed that they would have at least some level of care available to them should make people furious.

As has long been the case with the United States, we have waited until the last possible moment to address major issues with more than just rhetoric.

What will need to happen is that taxes will need to be raised. It's really that simple. We need to bring in more money than we are now so that we can collectively pay for the programs we will all need. And before anyone starts to complain about how our taxes are too high already, just remember that without a social safety net like universal health care in place, financial disaster is as close as any traffic accident, stroke, heart attack or major surgery for too many. You think the financial world is in tough shape when people default on home loans? Wait until millions of families go into bankruptcy every year because of health care related debts.

We are well past the time to fix our health care system. A new system must be created that is adequately funded, financially responsible, realistic, fair and accessible. We need a system that will approach care from the direction of doing the most good for the greatest number with the funds available.

We do not need a system that is wasteful, or panders to what patients feel they need. We need a system that is responsible in its care decisions and realistic in its judgments. We can no longer afford to pay specialists outrageous sums to perform procedures that have little to no impact on outcome or quality of life. Our new system must cover the basics like preventative care, medications and necessary hospitalizations. We need to stop spending massive amounts of money on care that only benefits the providers and not the patients.

And people need to understand that we cannot live forever. People die. It's what we are all destined to do – no one is exempt. But we have a hard time with this reality in the U.S. We feel like we should go on forever if we so desire.

Well, thinking like that is why we spend a majority of Medicare dollars in the last 6 months of a person's life. It's O.K. to want to live as long as possible. It's unacceptable to expect the rest of society to pick up the tab for those extra few months that can cost more than the previous 25 years.

Because any new responsible system would be available to all, it should be funded by all. This can be done via a tax on all things consumable. If we had such a tax, it would collect from those who eat caviar as well as those who live on cheap booze and everyone in between. No one would be exempt from paying, just as no one would be exempt from utilizing. And we can afford this – especially if we all stop paying premiums to insurance companies. Insurance can be handled here as it is in most other countries – as a supplement to the government provided minimum plan.

Fixing this mess will not be easy. The lobbyists are out there already, spending their money and exerting their influence on our government trying to keep the status quo. It will be necessary for all of us to be willing to vote out any representative who refuses to help build a realistic universal health system. Show them their jobs are not our concern. Get involved – write letters, educate yourselves, call offices of representatives and let them know you expect more from your government. Turn off Fox News and get real. The truth is painful, but it must be faced.

If we don't fix health care now, all the other things that need fixing won't matter.


  1. European countries have government paid social security. How come they are not severely suffering?

    And besides, US of A could well afford their social security payments...if they stopped feeding so much money to Pentagon. This would require that they stopped the fear-mongering about enemies everywhere first.

    AND: if US of A wants to have more money to give to Pentagon, they would need to make sure that their economy is supported by domestic manufacturing. There is no "service economy" - such a thing does not exist. In fact who-ever invented that concept should be hanged from his balls (most likely a dude anyway, and we would not want to hang a lady for such a thing).

    BESIDES: how comes the Eurozone is able to CONTINUE providing its citizens:
    A. government health care
    B. subsidized (in some countries: free) university education
    C. 4+ weeks vacations

    How come the Eurozone economy (which is often called "socialistic" - look at A, B, and C above) is capable of supporting multiple car manufacturers (MB, Porsche, Audi, VW, Peugeot, Citroen, etc) while the U.S. economy (which is quite capitalistic) is not even able to support 3 of them. Yes the Eurozone car manufacturers may have had to lay of people lately - but they have not been requiring hundreds of billions of $$ like their U.S. counterparts (and they STILL suffer after all that money).



  2. S clause -

    You are quite correct in your observations.

    We have a unique failure here to consider our fellow citizen. We neglect society's real needs so the government can fund the need it deems most urgent - our military industrial complex and our role in the world as self-appointed saviour.

    Our capitalistic system is, in reality, capitalism for the poor and socialism for the rich.

    My greatest hope with a change in administrations was that for a change the rest of society would be placed on the same footing as the privilaged. So far, some movement has been made, but it has been miniscule in my estimation.